The seven situations
- A rolling reserve is not released on the date in the contract
- The final settlement balance is withheld after termination
- Money recovered from the card schemes is not passed on
- A card scheme fine is deducted without the scheme’s own notice
- A chargeback fine is charged without a calculation
- Refund costs are charged beyond what the contract allows
- Several companies in one group have money held by the same provider
A rolling reserve is not released on the date in the contract
Illustrative example. The provider is an e-money institution licensed in the EEA.
What happened
- The provider holds back 10% of each month’s card takings as a reserve.
- The contract says the reserve is paid back in stages, after 180 and 270 days.
- The first payment arrives on time. After that the payments stop without explanation.
- The provider refers to a general "risk review" but never shows a decision.
Documents that matter
- The signed contract with the reserve and release schedule
- Monthly settlement reports showing the reserve building up
- Your written request for the held money to be released
- The provider’s replies about the partial release
What makes the file stronger
- A written release schedule with clear dates
- A written request for release sent after the release date
- At least one partial release that shows the schedule working
What makes it weaker
- The reserve was agreed orally, or the schedule was never signed
- No written request for release at the time
- The provider has a documented risk decision
What we would look at
We compare the release schedule with what was actually paid out and ask the provider to show the decision it relies on. The formal demand cites the schedule and the missing decision.
The final settlement balance is withheld after termination
Illustrative example. The provider is a payment institution licensed in the UK.
What happened
- The provider ends the contract "for cause" and keeps the final settlement balance.
- It gives "risk review" and possible future chargebacks as the reason.
- The period in which customers could raise chargebacks on the processed payments has passed.
- You ask in writing for an itemised set-off, and none arrives.
Documents that matter
- The contract and the termination notice
- The settlement ledger up to the termination date
- The chargeback history for the period after termination
- Your written requests for an account, and the provider’s acknowledgement
What makes the file stronger
- A written termination notice that states a reason
- The held balance shows as a single line on the ledger
- The chargeback period has clearly ended. It depends on the card scheme and the dispute reason, so we check it per transaction.
What makes it weaker
- The termination was oral or not documented
- The provider disputes the balance line by line
- Chargebacks can still be raised and new ones keep arriving
What we would look at
We rebuild the settlement balance from your records and the card scheme data, then demand payment under the contract. Any set-off the provider claims has to be shown and calculated.
Money recovered from the card schemes is not passed on
Illustrative example. The provider is an acquiring bank licensed in the EEA.
What happened
- Card scheme reports show amounts due back to you, for example corrected interchange fees or reversed assessments.
- The provider receives these credits but does not pass them on.
- Several settlement cycles are affected.
- When you ask for an account, the reply is general.
Documents that matter
- Card scheme reports for the cycles concerned
- The provider’s settlement reports showing no credit
- The contract terms on passing scheme credits through
- Any correspondence with the card schemes
What makes the file stronger
- You can identify the affected cycles from your own records
- The settlement reports clearly show no credit for those cycles
- The contract expressly requires the credits to be passed on
What makes it weaker
- The contract only deals with pass-through in general terms
- The cycles cannot be identified cleanly on your side
- The provider shows that it netted the credits against fines charged at the same time
What we would look at
We work out the amount cycle by cycle and demand it under the contract terms on passing credits through.
A card scheme fine is deducted without the scheme’s own notice
Illustrative example. The provider is a financial institution licensed in the EEA.
What happened
- A fine under a card scheme’s risk or integrity programme is taken from your settlement account.
- The provider shows no notice from the scheme, no decision letter and no calculation of the amount.
- You ask in writing for proof, and the reply is general.
Documents that matter
- The settlement ledger entry for the fine
- Your written requests for proof
- The provider’s replies
- The contract terms on passing on fines, and the scheme rules in force at the time
What makes the file stronger
- The fine is a clear, separate line on the ledger
- The contract only allows fines to be passed on when the scheme has actually assessed them
- Your request for proof came before any explanation from the provider
What makes it weaker
- The provider produces a scheme notice from the time that covers the fine
- The contract allows fines to be passed on without any scheme document
- Your volume in the period under review was well above normal
What we would look at
We ask the provider for the scheme’s notice and the calculation behind the fine. If the contract requires a scheme assessment and none is produced, we challenge the deduction under the contract.
A chargeback fine is charged without a calculation
Illustrative example. The provider is an e-money institution licensed in the EEA.
What happened
- The provider charges a fine for exceeding a chargeback ratio.
- The records do not show the calculation, the period looked at or the sales volume used.
- You dispute the ratio the fine is based on.
Documents that matter
- The settlement ledger with the fine
- Your chargeback history, from the scheme and from the provider
- The provider’s notice of the fine
- The contract terms on chargebacks, and your monthly volume reports
What makes the file stronger
- The fine is a separate line on the ledger
- You can rebuild the full chargeback history from your own records
- The contract sets a threshold and a method of calculation
What makes it weaker
- The fine is bundled into another deduction
- Your chargeback history is incomplete
- The contract leaves chargeback fines to the provider’s discretion
What we would look at
We recalculate the ratio from your chargeback history and sales volume. If the fine does not match the records, we dispute it under the contract.
Refund costs are charged beyond what the contract allows
Illustrative example. The provider is a payment institution licensed in the EEA.
What happened
- A subscription business sees refund-related charges on its ledger that go beyond the contract’s fee schedule.
- The provider calls it a refund cost pass-through but shows no calculation.
- You ask for the basis in the scheme rules or the contract, and the reply is general.
Documents that matter
- The settlement ledger showing the refund charges
- The contract’s fee schedule and pass-through terms
- The provider’s charge notices
- Your own refund volume reports
What makes the file stronger
- The fee schedule says which refund costs are passed on and at what rate
- The charge is a separate line on the ledger
- You have your own refund data to check the figures against
What makes it weaker
- The fee schedule gives the provider wide discretion
- The charge is folded into a general adjustment
- Your refund figures and the provider’s do not match
What we would look at
We check the charge against the fee schedule and your refund volume. Anything above what the contract allows is disputed under the contract.
Several companies in one group have money held by the same provider
Illustrative example. The provider is an acquirer licensed in the UK and operating across the EU.
What happened
- Several companies in one group process payments under one contract, or under closely related contracts with the same provider.
- Reserves, withheld settlements and unexplained deductions build up across the companies.
- Each company’s amount may look small on its own, but the total is significant.
- Amounts have been netted between the companies in the past without a clear paper trail.
Documents that matter
- The contract or contracts, and any group amendments or side letters
- Settlement ledgers for each company
- Reserve schedules for each company
- Group-level reconciliation and correspondence
What makes the file stronger
- A clear group structure, with each company’s contract clearly identified
- Settlement ledgers that can be attributed to each company
- Group-level correspondence with the provider about the issues
What makes it weaker
- Past netting between companies without a paper trail
- Changes to the group (sales, mergers, restructuring) that blur who is owed what
- Several terminations at different times, which the provider can use to question who may bring the claim
What we would look at
We reconcile at both company and group level and bring the claims together where the procedure allows.
What happens next
A file that resembles one of these still has to be reviewed on its own facts. Whether we take it on is decided after we review your documents. Send us the quick check, which takes about five minutes, and we reply within five business days with our initial view.
How the work is paid for is on How we work. More on stronger and weaker files is in the FAQ.