When you win a chargeback dispute, the money should come back to you. Sometimes it reaches your provider and stops there, especially after your account has been closed, and because it was never paid it does not appear on any statement.

You can find it by comparing the disputes you won with the credits you received. This article explains where these recoveries tend to stop, how the gap shows in your records, and what to ask the provider for.

What scheme passthrough is

When a cardholder disputes a transaction, the chargeback debit travels down the chain: scheme to acquirer, acquirer to PSP, PSP to you. Everyone knows this direction, because the debits arrive quickly and visibly.

The chain also runs the other way. When a dispute is decided in your favour (a successful representment, a pre-arbitration win, or a reversal because the issuer’s claim failed), the scheme credits the acquirer, the acquirer credits the institution, and the institution credits you. That last step is part of scheme passthrough, which also covers reversed fees and fines: the obligation to pass on what was recovered for your transactions. The recovery exists at scheme level whether or not it completes the last step. Our article on scheme passthrough covers the wider process; this one deals with what happens when the last step fails, and how to find it.

Where recoveries stop

Failures tend to happen in a few predictable places.

The last step is the one nobody checks. Movements from scheme to acquirer and from acquirer to institution are reconciled daily by staff on both sides. The step from institution to merchant often has no one reconciling it. The merchant lacks the scheme data to check, and the institution has no one assigned to it. Errors, batching shortcuts and “pending” balances build up where there is least audit pressure.

Closed accounts are exposed. Disputes outlive accounts. A merchant terminated in March still has disputes being decided in June, and the credits arrive at an institution that no longer has an active settlement account to pay them into. An institution already holding a reserve has little reason to point out that more of your money has arrived. If your account has been closed, the disputes that were still open on that date are the first place to look.

Net reporting hides the gap. Where chargeback activity is reported as one net figure per period (debits minus credits), individual recoveries are no longer visible. A net figure can absorb a lot. Missing credits can be found in gross reporting; in net reporting they stay hidden.

Currency and scheme fees make matching harder. A €1,000 reversal that arrives as €912 after conversion and fees is hard to pair with its chargeback by amount alone. Each deduction may be legitimate. Together they mean that only a reconciliation by case reference, not a read through the statements, shows what is missing.

Platform migrations break the link. Institutions change processing platforms, merge after acquisitions, and renumber case references when they do. Recoveries in progress during a migration are the most likely to fall between systems, and the hardest for the institution itself to find later. If your relationship spanned a rebrand or a migration, look closely at the months around it.

How the gap shows in your records

A missing credit leaves no line on a statement, but it can be traced in three places.

The win-rate gap. Your dispute portal records outcomes: disputes fought and disputes won. Your statements record credits. Count both for the same period. Illustrative example: a merchant who won 161 disputes and can find 118 reversal credits has 43 missing credits to explain, before pairing a single case.

What is left after pairing. Pair statement credits with dispute cases by reference, as described in the deductions article. Be conservative: where a credit could match two cases, give the institution the benefit. What is left after honest pairing is a list, with case numbers and amounts.

Nothing received after termination. List every dispute still open on your termination date and how it ended. Then look for any credit received after termination. Disputes decided after closure produce recoveries. If none reached you, either you lost every late dispute, which you can check, or the recoveries stopped one step short of you. This is the quickest of the three checks for a merchant whose account has been closed.

Putting a number on it

Before asking for anything, measure the gap honestly, because the check works in both directions. Some missing credits have innocent explanations: a reversal netted against a scheme fee in the same batch, a credit posted under a different case reference after a dispute was reopened, or a timing difference that clears one statement later. Check those explanations first, and take every item they account for off the list yourself, before the institution does. What remains is a cautious figure, and a cautious figure holds up better. Illustrative example: a list of 43 missing credits that falls to 31 when the provider checks it looks like an estimate; a list of 28 that stays at 28 looks like a finding.

The evidence this claim needs

The checks above give you a well-founded suspicion. Turning that into an amount needs the underlying records, and here the institution holds the half you cannot see.

What you hold, and should secure before portal access closes (see the 30-day checklist): complete dispute records with case references, reason codes and outcomes; gross-level statements for the whole relationship; and the clauses of the agreement on chargeback handling and passthrough.

What the institution holds, and what a written request should ask for: the scheme-level reconciliation for your merchant ID, showing what was credited to the institution for your transactions, case by case, and where each credit went. Ask specifically. “Please confirm all recoveries have been passed through” invites a one-line yes. “Please provide the scheme credit corresponding to case 4711-XXXX” has to be answered or visibly avoided. Either reply goes into the file.

An institution that has passed everything on can produce the reconciliation. If it answers a question about a specific case with a general description of its process, note which case it did not answer.

Why to check this alongside the rest of the file

Missing scheme recoveries rarely come alone. The same conditions (no one reconciling the last step, net reporting, a closed account) also tend to produce unsupported deductions and reserves held past their date, which is why we assess them as one file. A list of specific, case-referenced missing credits is also concrete evidence that sits alongside a disputed reserve in the same file.

If you were terminated with disputes still open, export the dispute list from the portal and attach it to the quick check together with your last statements.

This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.